ART FORM
Architecture and the Work of Charles Wright
CHAPTER TWO
WHAT ART LEAVES BEHIND
There is a familiar way of writing about architects who studied art: the early drawings are exhibited, the mature buildings are called sculptures, and a biographical line is drawn between them. The line is pleasingly simple and usually inadequate. Architecture does not become art by acquiring the silhouette of an artwork; it acquires its own artistic force when the means of building and inhabiting are transformed into a perceptual experience. Wright’s training matters because it opens that larger question.
Once stylistic resemblance has ceased to be a useful guide, Wright’s education offers another line of enquiry. The fine-art background matters, but not in the predictable way that a dramatic photograph might suggest.
Before architecture, Wright studied painting and sculpture. That fact helps explain a quality of attention, not an inevitable sequence of forms. A concrete building is not sculptural merely because its architect once made sculpture; nor does a framed view become a painting because the person who composed it understands pictorial space. The more revealing inheritance is a way of seeing relationships—mass against void, surface against light, the object against its setting—and then making those relationships carry the weight of occupation, construction and weather. 1
The comparison to Predator's optical camouflage is funny precisely because it is visually apt. A substantial public building appears to borrow the appearance of the garden in order to undermine its own visual autonomy. The joke should not conceal the architectural sophistication: the effect is contingent upon a real site, changing light and the experience of approaching and using the building. Nor does a resemblance to Koons establish direct influence. The analogy is valuable because it illuminates an operation visible in the work. 2,3
Stamp is an obvious starting point because it makes the artistic reading almost irresistible. In photographs the house can appear less constructed than placed, a collection of concrete masses held in an unusually tense relationship with water, vegetation and void. There is weight everywhere, but the weight is not inert. Openings remove enough material for the absence to become as important as the concrete surrounding it. Water extends and unsettles the apparent ground plane. The tropical vegetation beyond gives the hard geometries something against which to become even harder.
A sculpture can be concerned with gravity without providing shelter beneath its mass. Stamp's concrete has to perform structurally, environmentally and architecturally while remaining exposed to a demanding tropical climate. Water is not only an optical device. Openings are not simply voids cut into composition; they regulate movement, outlook, weather and the psychological relationship between protection and exposure. What appears in the photograph as an arrangement of mass and absence is also a building trying to make those conditions inhabitable. This is where Fine Art becomes more interesting rather than less relevant. Architecture does not cancel the compositional problem. It gives the composition opponents.
Painting provides an obvious analogy, though again it needs care. A colour does not remain the same perceptually when another colour is placed beside it. Composition is relational. Scale changes through adjacency. Empty space can become active. An edge can be sharpened, dissolved or made ambiguous by what surrounds it. Architecture inherits these possibilities but cannot leave them perceptual. Put a room beside a garden and the relationship involves more than composition. There is heat, drainage, security, movement, insects, sound, privacy and maintenance. Dissolve an edge and somebody eventually asks what keeps the rain out. That last question is not the defeat of the artistic idea. It is where the architectural idea begins.
This is where the history of twentieth-century and contemporary art becomes more productive than the generic adjective sculptural. Pop Art made surface, image, repetition and the unstable relationship between object and representation impossible to dismiss as superficial concerns. Warhol could make the reproduced image the subject; Koons could make reflection and immaculate surface uncomfortably complicit with desire and spectacle. Wright’s mirrored civic building is not a piece of Pop Art, but it inhabits a visual culture in which a surface can do far more than reveal the material beneath it.
Warhol's importance to this discussion is not that architecture should become advertising. It is that the reproduced image changed the conditions under which objects are seen. A building now exists in at least two worlds: the place where somebody encounters its temperature, scale, sound and thresholds, and the endless circulation of photographs in which it becomes a sign. The two can be radically different. Stamp House travels across screens and cinema with extraordinary ease; the person who enters it encounters the slower, heavier realities of concrete, water, shadow and weather. The friction between those lives is not a flaw in the image. It is one of the most revealing facts about contemporary architecture.
Installation art pushes the question elsewhere. The work is no longer necessarily a self-contained object placed before a spectator; it can reorganise the spectator’s awareness of a room, a route, a field of light or an entire site. Read that way, the Botanic Gardens project is interesting not because the façade is a clever mirror but because the mirror recruits the garden, weather and moving observer into the work. The building is never quite the same composition twice. It has outsourced part of its appearance to the world. Land Art offers another useful disturbance. Its strongest lesson for architecture is not that buildings should resemble earthworks. It is that site can cease to be the neutral ground upon which an autonomous object is displayed. The work may instead be inseparable from distance, topography, weather, season, movement and duration. Wright’s best buildings repeatedly become easier to understand when the site is treated as active material rather than scenery. 2
There is a further distinction between representation and re-presentation, and it makes the comparison with contemporary art more exact. Representation gives an image of something; re-presentation takes an already familiar object, image or condition and makes it newly available to perception, sometimes by changing its context, sometimes by changing the rules under which it can be seen. At Cairns Botanic Gardens Visitor Centre the garden is not merely represented on a mirrored façade. It is returned to the visitor as an unstable architectural image, its apparent location and boundaries continually remade by movement, weather and light. At (-) Glass House the operation is directed not only towards landscape but towards architecture’s own history: Philip Johnson’s famous Glass House is the canonical image being taken up, questioned and re-presented, with the minus sign declaring the act of subtraction. One project works upon the landscape before it; the other works upon a remembered architectural proposition. Both remain architecture, and both make perception part of the design.4
Olafur Eliasson offers a more recent and particularly revealing parallel. In The Weather Project, installed in Tate Modern’s Turbine Hall in 2003, a semicircle of light, a mirrored ceiling and artificial mist produced the apparition of an enormous interior sun. Visitors were not simply looking at an image of weather; they were occupying a constructed atmosphere, watching themselves become part of its representation. The comparison with Cairns is illuminating precisely because the operations differ. Eliasson brought an artificial weather-world into the museum. Wright’s mirrored building allows the actual tropical world to remake the building’s visible identity from outside. In both, reflection unsettles the distinction between the object and the conditions of its perception. But the civic building must do more than sustain an experience: it must endure weather, admit people, shelter them and continue functioning long after the moment of visual astonishment has passed.5
Robert Smithson's earthworks open another, almost opposite, line of thought. Where Pop Art exposes the strange autonomy of the circulating image, Land Art insists that place and time cannot be edited out so easily. A work can be altered by erosion, weather, distance and the changing conditions of its own visibility. The analogy does not turn a tropical house into an earthwork. It makes us look harder at the architectural encounter between an apparently self-contained form and a landscape that will never hold still. At Cairns Botanic Gardens Visitor Centre the mirror makes that encounter visible; at the coastal houses it is felt in the much less glamorous insistence of wind, salt and water.
Painting returns in a quieter way. Tropical light is not a neutral illumination system. It can bleach colour, deepen shadow, flatten a façade at noon and make the same material almost viscous late in the day. Concrete, water, vegetation, mirror, glass and darkness carry light differently. A painter learns very quickly that colour belongs partly to what surrounds it; architecture adds the inconvenience that the surrounding conditions keep changing. Some of Wright’s material decisions make more sense when read as arrangements of light-bearing surfaces rather than a palette of products.
This is a useful corrective to Stamp. If the Fine Art thesis only explains the most spectacular object in the portfolio, it is probably just a sophisticated way of saying Wright likes form. If it can also help us understand subtraction, editing, framing and restraint, it begins to describe something more durable. The Wright House offers another complication. Here the temptation of biography becomes particularly strong because an architect designing for himself is assumed to reveal the purest version of his thinking. This is rarely true. Architects are unusual clients but they are still clients, and self-designed houses contain compromises, experiments, budgets and changing lives like anybody else's. What they can reveal is which problems an architect chooses when given unusual freedom to choose them.
Across Wright's residential work, enclosure rarely feels neutral. Walls are thickened, removed, folded, screened or made visually unstable; views are not simply provided but controlled; landscape is sometimes admitted and sometimes held at a deliberate distance. The houses do not share one answer because the sites do not ask one question. This is why the word sculptural gradually becomes less satisfactory. Sculpture directs attention towards the building as object. Wright's more persistent concern may lie in the relationship between the object and everything acting upon it. The distinction becomes important once climate enters seriously. In tropical Queensland, light is not merely something that reveals form. It carries heat. Air is not empty space. It has temperature, moisture and movement. Water can be beautiful, necessary and destructive within the same afternoon. Vegetation can provide shade while increasing maintenance and affecting airflow. The visual world and the physical world are inconveniently inseparable.
If Wright's Fine Art background still matters here, it cannot operate simply by producing sculptural form. It has to operate through judgment: how different requirements are arranged, which relationships are made visible, where technical necessity becomes architectural opportunity and where architectural ambition has to concede to something that knows better. This is a much less glamorous account of the artist-architect. I think it is also more credible. The romantic version of the artist values freedom from constraint. Architecture repeatedly demonstrates that freedom is not the same thing as possibility. A building with no constraints is not a building; it is an image. The architectural imagination becomes consequential because it has to negotiate with things it cannot wish away.
The comparison should not be pushed too far. Buildings are not giant artworks, and architects who imagine otherwise tend to produce expensive evidence of the mistake. Architecture contains obligations to people that autonomous art does not necessarily share. It can affect safety, comfort, access, energy use, public space and the daily lives of people who never asked to participate in the architect's experiment. That ethical difference is important. It also makes the survival of artistic thinking more interesting. The artist in architecture cannot remain autonomous. The architect has to allow other knowledge to interfere. Mass still matters, but now somebody has to support it. Light still matters, but now it carries heat. Void still matters, but now somebody moves through it. Material still matters, but now it weathers. Composition still matters, but now the parts have independent reasons for being there. Architecture has not destroyed the artist. It has given the artist opponents.
Art, in this account, is neither an ornament added to architecture nor a private origin story that explains everything. It is one of the ways architectural imagination learns to notice possibilities that the ordinary description of a building leaves out. The next question is what happens to that imagination when the demands of a project become too complex to be held inside the familiar boundaries of a house.
The word opponents is useful because technical requirements are often described as though they merely constrain architecture. Gravity, weather, budget, regulation and construction become the dreary forces preventing the architect from making the pure building imagined at the beginning. That picture has always seemed suspicious. Without gravity there is no meaningful cantilever. Without weather there is no shelter. Without material resistance there is no detail worth resolving. Architecture does not become less artistic when reality interferes. Reality supplies much of the argument. Wright's work is strongest when the interference remains visible. At (-) Glass House the central act of subtraction is simultaneously compositional and environmental. Remove conventional enclosure and the spatial arrangement changes, but so do ventilation, privacy, security and the relationship between garden and room. The Australian Institute of Architects' national recognition of the project in both residential and sustainable architecture is significant for this reason. The categories overlap because the decision overlaps.
The Trouble with Categories | Contents | Architecture Gets Complicated
