ART FORM
Architecture and the Work of Charles Wright
CHAPTER EIGHT
MAKING DIFFERENT THINGS BELONG
History offers no shortage of buildings that are admired for a single dominant quality: a daring span, an extraordinary roof, a beautiful plan, a cultivated garden. The more elusive achievement occurs when such qualities become impossible to prise apart. That is why Bawa, Lautner, Frank Lloyd Wright and Niemeyer are useful comparisons here. They do not form a chain of influence leading to Wright, and their methods were far from identical. Each, in a different register, made technical and spatial relationships into the substance of architectural invention.
Some buildings seem to have been assembled from independently resolved parts. Others make it difficult to imagine their structure, light, movement, material and landscape ever having been separate. That second condition is not achieved by calling a project integrated. It arises when an architectural decision can answer several demands at once, so that what is necessary becomes expressive and what is expressive becomes useful.
Frank Lloyd Wright made the question almost impossible to avoid because he repeatedly tried to extend architectural order beyond the conventional limits of the building. Structure, furniture, glazing, ornament, landscape and circulation could participate in a larger composition, and his idea of organic architecture insisted that unity should arise from the nature of the whole rather than from an assemblage of independent parts. There is an authoritarian edge to this version of wholeness. If every chair, light fitting, window and piece of furniture belongs to the total composition, the architect's responsibility can slide easily into the architect's control. Clients have inconvenient habits. They buy furniture. They move things. They hang pictures where the composition had not anticipated pictures. Life is an unreliable collaborator.
Yet the architectural achievement remains difficult to dismiss. At Fallingwater, for example, the relationship among rock, water, cantilever, movement and occupation cannot be reduced convincingly to a building placed beside a landscape. The architecture derives much of its force from making the distinction unstable. One may criticise the mythology surrounding the project, its technical history or Wright's treatment of clients and collaborators without losing sight of the larger proposition: the building is trying to make site, structure and inhabitation part of the same thought. That phrase—the same thought—needs qualification. Buildings are never literally produced by one thought. They emerge through revisions, arguments, calculations, accidents, construction decisions and compromises. The phrase describes the effect of coherence, not the historical reality of a perfectly unified act of conception. That distinction becomes essential when we reach Charles Wright. Before doing so, Geoffrey Bawa shifts the terms considerably. 1
Bawa's architecture is often discussed through tropical modernism, but the label can obscure how strange his spatial intelligence actually was. His work in Sri Lanka repeatedly makes buildings difficult to separate from gardens, courtyards, terrain, water and movement. At Lunuganga, the distinction becomes particularly unstable because architecture and landscape were developed through a long process of adjustment rather than a single finished composition. Bawa's version of wholeness is therefore less object-like than Frank Lloyd Wright's. The architecture often emerges through sequences: compression and release, darkness and light, covered and uncovered space, distant views and intimate courts. A roof may matter less as an object than for the shade it creates and the territory beneath it. A wall can become significant because of what it withholds until movement reveals something beyond. The whole is experienced through time. 2
The resemblance to Bawa should not be overstated. Bawa's work emerged from Sri Lankan histories, landscapes, patronage and cultural conditions that cannot be transferred to Far North Queensland as though “tropical” were a universal architectural nationality. Nor does Wright generally possess Bawa's almost archaeological accumulation of courts, roofs, walls and gardens. The comparison is useful because both make the tropics more than a climatic specification. Climate changes spatial relationships.
This is particularly clear in projects such as the Chemosphere and the Sheats-Goldstein Residence, although in very different ways. The former concentrates an extraordinary amount of architectural identity into the relationship between site, support and elevated enclosure. The latter develops a more expansive interaction among concrete, landscape, view, shelter and interior experience. Lautner is relevant to Wright not because both architects have made dramatic houses. That category is too broad to be useful. What matters is their willingness to allow physical necessity to become architectural character. There is a difference between showing structure and thinking structurally. Architecture can expose beams, columns and connections while remaining conceptually indifferent to them. Conversely, a building can conceal much of its structural system while having been fundamentally shaped by the behaviour of forces, spans, supports and material. 3
The comparison with Bawa is most productive where it resists visual resemblance. Bawa's architecture frequently makes a journey through gardens, courtyards, shade and thresholds the central event. Wright's work may be more abrupt, more geometrically emphatic and more willing to make structure visible. Yet both can be examined through the proposition that landscape is not an accessory attached after the building is designed. Lautner offers a second, almost opposite lens: the moment when an engineered span or roof ceases to be a technical accomplishment and becomes the room's governing spatial experience.
Stamp makes the comparison obvious, perhaps too obvious. Its concrete invites discussion of mass and structural behaviour before the critic has even entered the house. More revealing are projects where the relationship is quieter. The Edge, for instance, uses projection, elevation and the relationship between building and terrain to create architectural experience that cannot be detached completely from the problem of support. The visual effect is not simply a shape selected and subsequently held in place. This is where Lautner becomes both helpful and misleading. 4
(-) Glass House and Stamp House do not need to resemble one another closely if both are trying to reorganise relationships among climate, enclosure and occupation. Cairns does not need Stamp's concrete monumentality if its material strategy can produce a different negotiation between architecture and landscape. Trinity does not need to look domestic if the underlying concern with climate, movement and spatial connection can survive the institutional programme. The continuity, if it exists, is operational. This is close to the observation made earlier that the buildings share verbs rather than a face, but the distinction has developed since then. A verb describes an action: wrapping, lifting, screening, framing, opening. Synthesis asks what happens when several such actions become consequences of the same decision. 5
A roof may shade, span, collect water and define social territory. None of those functions is extraordinary individually. The architecture becomes interesting when changing the roof to solve one problem would alter all the others. That is what I mean by one thought. Not a flash of genius arriving complete in the architect's head, and certainly not one person controlling every technical consequence. The phrase describes a degree of interdependence. The building has been thought through sufficiently that its important decisions begin carrying more than one kind of responsibility. This is difficult architecture to make because the easiest way to solve a complicated problem is to divide it. There is nothing inherently wrong with division. Professional knowledge depends upon it. The structural engineer needs to isolate structural behaviour long enough to understand it. Environmental modelling requires its own abstractions. Cost planning needs categories. Regulations divide buildings into measurable requirements because regulation would be impossible if every project were treated as an indivisible work of art. The danger comes later, when the divisions become the building.
Bawa, Lautner and Frank Lloyd Wright help because none provides a template. Bawa demonstrates how landscape, climate and movement can become spatially inseparable. Lautner shows how physical and structural possibility can generate experience rather than merely support it. Frank Lloyd Wright represents the extraordinary ambition, and the corresponding danger, of treating architecture as a total composition. Charles Wright arrives after all of them, in a profession where that ambition has to coexist with forms of knowledge and collaboration too complex to belong to one person. If there is a contemporary version of the total architectural project here, it cannot depend upon possessing the whole. It has to depend upon maintaining relationships within it. That is harder than it sounds, particularly when other people are involved. And from this point onward, they increasingly are.
How Much Does an Architect Need to Know? | Contents | Variation Without Repetition
