ART FORM
Architecture and the Work of Charles Wright
CHAPTER NINE
VARIATION WITHOUT REPETITION
Jazz is a particularly treacherous analogy for architecture because almost any building can be described as rhythmic if the critic is sufficiently determined. The stronger comparison concerns the long education that makes improvisation possible. A player learns harmony, phrasing, ensemble discipline, technique and the history of the instrument before being able to depart from familiar patterns with purpose. What appears spontaneous may be the product of years of concentrated understanding. The analogy is illuminating only if it is applied to architectural decisions rather than to picturesque curves.
The comparison with earlier architects illuminates the work, but it does not produce a family resemblance that can explain every project. Music suggests another way to understand continuity without repetition.
Wright’s relationship with music is not a convenient metaphor invented by criticism: he plays saxophone, and his listening extends through John Coltrane, Wayne Shorter, Alice Coltrane, Keith Jarrett and Jan Garbarek. The connection matters less as a source of shapes than as a way of thinking about creative knowledge. Serious improvisation is not the absence of discipline. It is what becomes possible when discipline has been absorbed deeply enough to support decisions that could not have been rehearsed in advance. 1
Coltrane, Shorter, Alice Coltrane, Jarrett, Garbarek and Ravi Coltrane are useful here for reasons more precise than the familiar architectural cliché about music. Improvisation offers a model of identity that does not require the repetition of appearances. A musician can remain recognisable while changing tempo, register, ensemble, harmonic language or density because character may reside in decisions rather than motifs. Architecture can work similarly. A practice need not repeat a roof, material or silhouette if a deeper disposition persists in the way it handles climate, boundary, structure, landscape, movement and consequence.
Miles Davis could alter ensembles, technologies and musical territories radically without listeners concluding that the absence of yesterday's sound meant the disappearance of authorship. David Bowie could change appearance, collaborators and genre while continuity persisted through something more elusive than a repeated formal vocabulary. The comparison becomes dangerous if pushed too far—musicians do not have to obtain planning approval for a chord change—but the cultural expectation is revealing. We permit musicians to change. Architects are often rewarded for becoming recognisable.
Coltrane's recordings can differ enormously from one another while remaining recognisably his. The distance between the relatively concise playing of the 1950s, the harmonic intensity associated with the classic quartet and the increasingly exploratory late work is not cosmetic. The music changes its relationship with structure, duration, harmony and collective improvisation. Yet the listener does not need the same melody, tempo or instrumentation repeated forever in order to recognise continuity. That is interesting for architecture because architects are normally identified in almost the opposite way. Recognition tends to depend upon recurrence. Certain materials appear. Roofs take familiar forms. Windows acquire characteristic proportions. Plans repeat organisational preferences. Eventually the critic can walk into a building and announce the architect before checking the credits. This is often described as having a language. 2
Coltrane is particularly instructive because the freedom of his later work did not arise from ignorance of structure. It emerged from a formidable technical and harmonic command, an ear trained by countless hours of practice, and an appetite for moving beyond familiar solutions. That does not make an architectural plan equivalent to a solo. Buildings have clients, regulations, gravity and a duration fundamentally unlike performance. But the comparison helps distinguish repetition of an outward result from continuity of a creative intelligence.
Consider framing. One project may frame a distant landscape through a precisely controlled opening. Another may frame vegetation through reflection. A third may use structure or circulation to reveal space progressively. The formal result can be entirely different while the underlying interest in controlling perception remains. The same applies to lifting. A building raised in response to terrain, water, outlook or climatic exposure need not resemble another raised building. The architectural consequence depends upon why it was lifted and what the separation from ground produces. These are not signatures in the conventional sense. They are habits of decision. This is where I think Wright's work becomes easier to understand.
Improvisation is frequently misunderstood as freedom from structure. Serious improvisational music tends to depend upon the opposite: intense knowledge of structure sufficient to permit meaningful departure from it. A musician can stretch time because time is understood. Harmony can be displaced because its expectations are present even when they are being resisted. Architecture has a related relationship with constraint. A building cannot improvise after construction in the way a musician can during performance, but design itself proceeds through repeated encounters with things that refuse the initial idea. Site, climate, structure, budget, regulation and client requirements behave rather like propositions to which the architect has to respond. The response changes the next possibility.
Bawa understood this with unusual sophistication. His architecture often depends upon movement through sequences rather than the apprehension of a single total object. Lautner could make the approach to a room as important as the room itself. Frank Lloyd Wright manipulated compression and release so deliberately that movement becomes one of the means by which the architecture is composed. Wright's work belongs to this broader architectural territory without needing music to legitimise it. What music does is remind us that sequence is not merely a collection of moments. The relationship between moments produces the experience. This is obvious in a piece of music. A note means something partly because of what came before it and what we expect might follow. Architecture is less temporally strict because occupants can reverse direction, stop, leave or enter through another door, but spatial sequence still creates expectation.
Nor does improvisation mean a building is casually invented. The more technically demanding the architecture becomes, the more knowledge must be present before freedom can be exercised responsibly. That is the productive paradox linking music to the Artist–Engineer interpretation: imagination is expanded, not diminished, by technical mastery.
The music analogy finally earns its place not by making buildings sound poetic but by explaining why technical discipline and formal unpredictability need not be enemies. Once the discipline has become part of the imagination, the next building need not look like the last. It still has to answer the world in which it is made, beginning with the very real lines that define and complicate its site.
At the coast, a line on a drawing can become an argument about who or what a building protects. A retaining edge may be a landscape intervention, a structural device and a defence against erosion; a raised floor may be a spatial experience and a flood strategy. Wilson Beach House at Dicky Beach and the proposed Wonga resort suggest a change in scale of responsibility, from the line enclosing a room to the line negotiating an unstable territory. The design implications are compelling even where the long-term environmental outcomes remain to be demonstrated.
Making Different Things Belong | Contents | The Lines We Draw
