ART FORM
Architecture and the Work of Charles Wright
INTRODUCTION
ARCHITECTURE HAS A PROBLEM
The first surprise is the distance between the buildings. A house of monumental concrete appears to have little in common with a reflective pavilion in a tropical garden; a dwelling that seems to dissolve into its surroundings has little obvious kinship with a hospital, a school or a proposed resort stretching across a coastal landscape. Yet these are all parts of Charles Wright’s architectural work. The temptation is to search for a recognisable shape that might make them belong together. The more rewarding enquiry begins when that search fails. 3
Architectural categories are helpful until they begin pretending to explain everything. Brutalism, Critical Regionalism, Tropical Modernism, organic architecture, high-tech and parametricism illuminate different aspects of buildings, but none can stand in for looking closely. Interpretations applied to Wright’s work have included Artist–Engineer, polymath, Total Architect and Resilient Tropical Modernism. They are useful only insofar as they clarify the architecture: the decisions made, the problems addressed and the new possibilities opened by the work.
Architecture has always had an unreasonable job description. Vitruvius knew this two thousand years ago when he described a discipline requiring familiarity with drawing, geometry, history, philosophy, music, medicine, law and astronomy. Vitruvius was not asking the architect to become expert in every field; buildings were already understood as places where different kinds of knowledge collided, and architecture could not retreat into beauty because buildings had to stand up, or into engineering because somebody had to live in them, or into usefulness because human beings have an inconvenient habit of wanting their lives to mean something. 1
The modern world has not made the task easier. A substantial building now carries structure, fire engineering, acoustics, hydraulics, mechanical and electrical systems, accessibility, energy, planning law, environmental regulation, cost planning, construction logistics, landscape, cultural questions and a small army of specialists whose expertise the architect would be foolish to pretend to possess. Clients, governments, builders, neighbours, insurers and eventual occupants enter the process as well, while weather, gravity, money and time remain stubbornly indifferent to the elegance of the concept sketch. After all of those forces have had their say, the result is still expected to become architecture.
The better place to begin is architecture itself. There is a respectable argument that architecture is the most comprehensive of the arts, although the claim becomes pompous very quickly if it is mistaken for a hierarchy of cultural worth. Painting can achieve things architecture cannot, music can move through time with freedoms unavailable to buildings, sculpture can pursue form without providing emergency egress, and literature can enter consciousness directly. Architecture’s peculiar difficulty comes from its inability to remain pure. Its closest relatives may be opera and cinema, synthetic arts that gather many other arts into a single event, except that architecture makes the scenery weigh thousands of tonnes and asks people to inhabit it for generations.
That physical persistence changes the stakes. When an opera fails, the curtain eventually comes down, and a dreadful film releases its audience after a couple of hours. A bad building may remain on the corner for seventy years, accumulating consequences in the lives of people who work, sleep, recover, learn or grow old inside it. They pay to heat and cool it, clean it, repair it and find their way through it; they discover whether the western glazing was really a good idea in February and whether the roof junction that looked elegant in section keeps out rain. Architectural decisions become physical facts in other people’s lives, which gives beauty an ethical burden rather than making beauty less important.
Architecture can absorb the concerns of other arts without becoming subordinate to them. Painting may sharpen an attention to colour, surface and light; sculpture may intensify an understanding of mass, void, gravity and balance; installation can disturb the assumed edge of the object; Land Art can make landscape inseparable from the work; Pop can turn image, reflection and spectacle into serious subjects. Architecture accepts all of those possibilities and then subjects them to weather, structure, access, cost, construction, occupation and time. An architect can make a painterly judgement and discover that the red thing weighs six tonnes.
Cairns Botanic Gardens Visitor Centre makes the distinction vivid. A public building is placed beside an extravagant tropical garden and, instead of competing with it as an object, substantial mirrored surfaces allow the garden to steal the architecture. Trees, sky, people and weather migrate onto the facade so that the object remains physically present while its visual identity becomes unstable. The camouflage effect is close enough to Predator to be funny, but the joke opens a serious architectural question: where does the work end when the environment becomes part of its visible surface? Installation and Pop offer useful ways of thinking about the effect, yet the building is not an installation or a Pop artwork. It has doors, public obligations, weathering, structure and maintenance; the artistic question becomes architectural precisely because it cannot remain only an image. 2
The (-) Glass House performs another conceptual trick, and its title is already a small act of criticism. Philip Johnson’s Glass House of 1949 had become one of modernism’s canonical images: the transparent pavilion, its enclosure seemingly dissolved into landscape. Wright takes that recognisable architectural proposition and re-presents it through subtraction. The minus sign is deliberate. This is not simply a tropical variation upon a famous glass box, nor a question of how much glazing a house needs. The architectural original becomes conceptual material for another building, one that asks what happens when the apparent certainty of the glass-house image is subjected to the realities of tropical occupation. Rain, insects, privacy, security, heat and air movement do not spoil the artistic proposition; they give the re-presentation its architectural consequences. Fine Art matters here when it sharpens the act of seeing, not because architecture ceases to be architecture.4
The work becomes more complicated as its scale and obligations change. Kyneton Hospital Redevelopment and the Wimmera Base Hospital masterplanning work bring architecture into contact with institutions that cannot be reduced to formal theatre. Primary health-care work in the Torres Strait introduces remoteness, island logistics, climate, community and maintenance. Toorak Pavilion shifts the field to substantial metropolitan residential architecture and the Yarra landscape, while Wonga Beach Resort brings tourism, coast, ecology, cultural experience and Country into a project of a different order again. These works matter not as a roll-call proving versatility but because each changes the conditions under which architecture has to become coherent.
The central subject is architectural invention: the moment when a problem of structure, weather, material, occupation or landscape becomes the beginning of the architecture rather than an obstacle imposed upon it. A good architectural idea does not wait for the technical work to be completed before acquiring its form. Its technical and artistic dimensions develop together. That is the territory ART FORM investigates.
ART FORM | Contents | The Trouble with Categories
